The Road Not Taken: How Britain Narrowly Missed a Revolution 1381-1926 by Frank McLynn

Frank McLynn takes us on a journey through British history to explain why, despite our collective moaning about how it screws us over,  we’ve never managed to turn ‘The Establishment’ out on its arse. McLynn looks in-depth at various almost-revolutionary occasions – the Peasants’ Revolt of 1381, the Jack Cade rising of 1450, the Pilgrimage of Grace in 1536, the English Civil War of the 1640s, the Jacobite Rising of 1745-6, the Chartist Movement of 1838-48 and the General Strike of 1926 – to consider why we never achieved the genuine root and branch social and political change experienced by some of our European neighbours.

It’s a 500-pages-of-small-text whopper of a book, a bit male-centric (although McLynn admits and seeks to remedy this with occasional stories of women’s involvement), and at times I wished for a thematic rather than a chronological approach which would concisely answer the exam question of why we failed to transform these significantly tumultuous periods into pivotal change. But the point is that there is no simple answer to this quandary, but multiple, interacting factors, including the fact we’re an island of four countries with competing interests, defended primarily by a sea-based Navy rather than a land-based army, were early to industrialize, and built an Empire of subjugated peoples abroad which conveniently created some delusion about how subjugated we were ourselves in dear old Blighty.

However McLynn’s detailed observation of these events and the characters that led them is riveting and made me view them in an entirely new light. I was –  naively –  shocked by the pure violence that accompanied the early struggles, and the readiness of the state, including relatively recently when protest was comparatively peaceful, to use its force to crush the pesky proles: if you’ve got mad love for Winston Churchill, read about his approach to the General Strikers in 1926 and tell me if he is still worthy of National Hero Of The People status. Most of all, I was surprised by how close we actually got to revolution at times – for example, my History A-level arguably mis-sold the Chartist impact (which is even worse than mis-selling PPI, whatever those cold-callers tell you), and my previous assessment that the Jacobites were just a bunch of nincompoops rollicking around in ruffs pretending to be King James was clearly misjudged.

Therefore I wonder if our teachers should big-up these stories of near-revolution to encourage our young people to believe that change is actually possible. Even if we never achieved  a genuinely trans-class revolt, and even though the ‘commoners’/ latterly working classes were fragmented and bizarrely deferential (to a monarchy they refused to believe could do them any wrong, to gentry/middle class leaders who later sold them down the river, and to religion), the point is: there were some moments when ‘The Establishment’ was genuinely pooping its velvet, diamond studded pants. Who knew, for example, that a group of Brentwood Essex boys launched the Peasants’ Revolt? We need to tell these stories. Thank you, Frank.

nrm_1414753366-towie_boys
The boys from ITV’s The Only Way Is Essex. Their forefathers almost caused a revolution in the 14th Century. Look me in the eye and tell me it could not happen again. With thanks to SugarScape for this picture of fine British men.
Advertisements

8 Comments Add yours

  1. Brilliant review, will add this to my reading wishlist!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Jan Hicks says:

    This sounds right up my street. I’m trying not to buy books until I’ve reduced my pile somewhat, but if I see it out in the wild, I might have to snare it. I read They All Love Jack, about Jack the Ripper, last year and that had a similar slant on The Establishment and the subjugated masses.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ah now that sounds like an interesting book! I have been looking for a book which deals with the Ripper case from a bit more of a sociological etc basis, ie how the murders were viewed in the context of the society they took place in, rather than just focusing on the gore..

      Like

      1. Jan Hicks says:

        They All Love Jack is brilliant. Bruce Robinson (of Withnail & I fame) is incandescently angry about the cover up and the treatment of the women. He’s also scornful of the traditional Ripperology. I’m telling everyone to read it! I bought it for one of my nephews for Xmas and apparently the whole family are fighting over it.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Right, it’s on the list! I hate the semi-pornographic approach to the victims. They were real women.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. lotaboutlife says:

    Good insight.. I have always believed that history is manipulated by people with power. Winston Churchill have been in India and I recently found out about his racist approach towards Indians.. Anyways, loved the review and will sure see if I can get my hands on the book.. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s another interesting perspective on Churchill! I know he is a hero to many but his actions here really opened my eyes, and your point adds to that.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s