Savage Girls and Wild Boys by Michael Newton

This unusual book may rate as one of my more peculiar charity shop finds, with thanks to British Heart Foundation Bromley. Savage Girls and Wild Boys tells the sad stories of children who have grown up outside the framework of the family/care unit, either brought up by animals in the wilderness, or locked in solitary confinement. It starts with the mythological tale of Romulus and Remus, and travels through time to recount historical examples such as Peter The Wild Boy in 18th century Germany and more recent examples such as Genie in 1970s America.

It’s more of a scientific and anthropological analysis than the voyeuristic piece it could have been, given the subject matter and our predilection for tales of abusive childhoods. Michael Newton seeks to explain how society has reacted to these isolated children – the questions their experiences prompt about major subjects such as evolution (e.g. whether these children provide living examples of humanity’s primitive state, given their isolation from outside influence), and language (e.g. whether their lack of language skills has ramifications for their capacity for thought, and for having an identity, or even a soul…), and how our understanding of what their experience can tell us has usually been influenced by the prevailing scientific theory of the period and has therefore changed over time. There is also an interesting review of how these ‘wild children’ have been represented in literature – I’ll never watch  Jungle Book with the same innocence ever again.

Predictably, as interesting as this analysis is, overall it remains a distressing read. Consider, for example, this vignette of Kasper Hauser, who was found wandering the streets of Nuremberg as a 16 year old in 1828 claiming to have spent his childhood imprisoned in a dungeon, and whose tale includes a kidnapped German royal heir and a murder plot involving a British aristocrat:

In August 1828, (his teacher) showed him for the first time the sight of the stars at night. Hauser, as always when presented with something new, fell into a stunned reverie. On coming from this absorbed stillness, Hauser wept that for so long he had been kept from the sight of such beauty.

And, as well as it obviously being difficult to read about children being unloved or uncared for, the fact that there is a pattern of ambitious scientists capitalizing on their misfortune to further their scientific research, and then dumping them shortly once they cease to be useful, means that there aren’t many happy endings in this book.

So, brace yourself if you are going to read it…and perhaps have this Duran Duran classic to hand to lift your spirits (thank you, YouTube). Dunno about you, but Simon Le Bon in leathers always cheers me up, and if my Jason can age as well as John Taylor, then job’s a good’un.

Advertisements

5 Comments Add yours

  1. rltsite says:

    I think all of the questions at the heart of these stories are fascinating! Especially the linguistic element- thinking about language shaping your thoughts just makes my brain explode, frankly. What was it that made you lose interest, the writing style or the subject matter?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hello! Oh I didn’t lose interest – the questions are indeed mindblowing as you say! But I got to the end of it feeling educated but rather depressed – I think the fact the closing example is as recent as thd 1970s made it all rather real and made me think of the kiddies. So as I say, prepare yourself for that emotional inpact – but enjoy the anthropology/science bit!

      Like

  2. bookheathen says:

    Just wanted to say how glad I am that you found this book at British heart Foundation. Though it wasn’t one of mine, BHF is where I go when I’m having a clear out. I never get to know whether people buy them or not.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Jan Hicks says:

    What an interesting sounding book. I always thought Kaspar Hauser was a folktale, so I’ve learnt something from your review. I wonder what the odds are on a copy being in our local BHF or Oxfam shop. I’ll keep my eyes peeled.

    14 year old me loved the sight of Le Bon in leather being dunked on a windmill blade, so thanks for the YouTube video. You’ve made a middle aged woman happy!

    I’m catching up on blog posts, by the way, so you might have a flurry of comments from me!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks Jan – I always enjoy reading your thoughts on a book!

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s